
The theme of International Open Access Week this year is the cost of knowledge. This shines a light both on the major contributions made by the research sector itself (and how these are then captured by private actors) and on the lack of transparency around costs in the publishing field.
One argument made to justify the continued use of paywalls and high fees for article processing is that this helps to maintain the infrastructure for safeguarding scientific integrity, from peer review to editorial checks and the handling of misconduct. Without these business models, the story goes, these services can no longer be provided. Yet given how little transparency there is on publishing costs, it is rarely clear how much of what institutions and funders pay actually goes towards integrity.
Integrity is indeed a major issue. It is essential not only to maintain the quality of science, but also to safeguard the trust of the public and funders. Stories of malpractice damage confidence in research as a whole.
The question then is whether closing access (either to reading through subscription fees, or to publishing through article processing charges) is an acceptable ‘sacrifice’.
Knowledge Rights 21’s latest Insights paper on openness and integrity answers this question, based on an analysis of official codes of ethics and research integrity from 18 EU Member States, as well as other European and international sources.
It finds that in the vast majority of cases, the act of sharing outputs itself is an essential part of ensuring integrity. As a result, models that make this more difficult, for example through article processing charges that price some researchers out of publishing, sit uneasily with integrity goals.
Beyond this, most countries stress that research articles should reach the general public, not just the scientific community. Many explicitly make Open Access, Open Science and/or wider open research practices a key part of their efforts to boost integrity and ethics.
The implication is clear: the restriction of access itself can represent a barrier to the fulfilment of research integrity objectives. Integrity services cost money and need sustainable funding. But restricting access is not the only way to pay for them, and by Europe’s own standards it carries an integrity cost of its own. Diamond open access, where neither readers nor authors pay, already shows that other models can work.
In upcoming discussions on the European Research Area Act and copyright reforms, it will be worth remembering that openness contributes not only to goals around competitiveness and equity, but also to integrity. Policymakers have the opportunity to support progress here by guaranteeing, through a secondary publication right, that researchers can make their publicly funded work openly available, whatever contract they have signed. It’s the right thing to do, for science and for the public that pays for it.
23 October 2026